Luna is a beautiful green moth that is only seen at night. Luna is also a beautiful girl who shows herself only at night, and only to her sister, 15-year-old Regan. By day, Luna is really Liam, Regan's 17-year-old brother, a senior in high school, academically brilliant by all accounts. But Liam is transgender; since he was very young he has known that he is a girl accidentally born with a boy's body. As he approaches his 18th birthday, Liam/Luna begins to "transition", to show the world his true identity. Regan is the only other person who knows his secret, a burden that proves to be almost too much to bear.On the surface, Luna is a "problem novel" written for young adults, joining a host of other books that deal with issues that teens encounter. What sets it apart from the others is the groundbreaking subject matter. I can't think of another children's book that deals with this issue. The author, Julie Ann Peters, handles it lovingly. She does a good job of showing the conflicting emotions that Luna's transition causes to the people closest to her, but she makes it clear that in the end Luna has an essential right to be who she is -- and when she is free, then the people around her are free as well.
I found Luna to be a beautiful, harrowing, poignant book.
A few years ago I taught a first grade boy, whom I am fairly certain is transgender. He simply saw himself as a girl. It was/is tough; he's a biracial child, with an African-American father who isn't real into having his son be a girl. I spent a lot of time on the phone with his mom, mainly because this child also had major anxiety issues that made it hard for him to learn. One evening we were talking, and she said, "I really hope this is just a phase he's going through." She paused, and then she said, "But it's not, is it? I just need to love him the way he is." His mom was great; for his birthday that year she bought him an American Girl doll and a Powerpuff Girls t-shirt. I think he's had a fairly positive experience in school so far. In my class he loved dressing up in a pink tutu (a lot of boys seem to love the pink tutu), drawing beautiful pictures of princesses and cheerleaders, and hanging around with the girls. He'll be a fifth grader this year. I worry about him as he gets into adolescence.
We actually have a full time teacher in our school district whose job it is to facilitate support of LGBT students throughout all the schools.
There is a transgendered person that I see in my part of town a lot. It's clearly a man dressed like a woman -- clothes, jewelry, make-up -- S/he dresses more frilly than I ever do. I see her most frequently in thrift stores, I always say hello, but I've never struck up a conversation -- which I'd like to at some point. One day, however, I overheard the sweetest conversation in St. Vincent dePaul's. There was a long line for the fitting rooms. S/he was in line, and right behind her was a young mom with two little girls. One of the girls was staring and staring at this man in a dress; she finally said, "Your dress is pretty." S/he said, "Thank you! So is yours," and they smiled at each other for a while.
I hope that some day our society will reach a point where we recognize that there is an infinite spectrum of what constitutes "human-ness" and we allow all people to be who they are -- from the youngest child to the oldest adult.
Anyway ... Luna. Highly recommended.





12 comments:
When Jeff and I came back to Green Bay I had never seen a man wear woman's clothing and I was working at Family dollar here in town. Well I turned around and there was this man standing there wearing his wife's nighty. I mean a speg strapped nighty with that fur on the bottom nighty. High heels and everything. Yes he was married on top of this. I almost chocked on my piece of candy I was chewing on. I have no predjudices but it was far from anything I had ever seen before.
Reading this post made me weepy for all of those who are rejected for being who they are.
The other night, I was having dinner with my step-daughter (12) and the song Supermodel by RuPaul came up, she loves it.
So we watched the video on youtube after we ate and then had a long talk about transexual and transgendered people... from those who simply like to dress as the other gender to the actual have the whole operation.
She was fascinated. I asked if that if she met someone like that would she be afraid.
She said maybe a little bit yes, but that she would want to be nice to them.
The book sounds great Suzy.
As ever- I thank you.
This post got to me, too. I love the story of the transgender man and the little girl at the end. If only our society didn't suck the kindness out of people, what a lovely place this could be.
Tweetey, I agree that it can be startling. I wonder if a man wearing a slinky nightie isn't being a bit of an exhibitionist, as opposed to someone who simply feels more comfortable in opposite-gender clothes. Don't know. I think it is OK to be surprised.
That was perhaps the one thing that bothered me in the book: the first time Luna went out in public dressed as a woman, SHE was freaked
out by other people's reactions. But that might have been the genuine feelings of an adolescent who wants to be accepted more than anything else.
Fran -- your step daughter could probably read the book, especially if you read it too. My 12 year old read it.
DCup, that scene warmed my heart.
Your review made me think of the transitioning boy in California this year who was murdered by a classmate, in school. A thoroughly hateful hate crime.
I've put this book on request at my library. I was glad to see they had it.
And yeah, your student will have a hell of a time in junior high, unless s/he is placed in a school where the folks who run the place are ready and equipped to help out.
As a side-note, I highly recommend a very sweet and charming film on a related topic, Normal, which stars Tom Wilkinson and Jessica Lange. Great stuff.
I think on the whole, Madison is a good place to see if you fall outside of what's considered the range of "normal" in terms of sexual and/or gender orientation. There are a lot of resources. And at least in my part of town (where we have a neighborhood lovingly referred to as "Dyke Heights") few people bat an eye at anything. But I'm sure it will still be hard for this kid.
Thank you for the film recommendation. I'm putting it on hold at the library right now.
"Be" not "see". Madison is a good place to BE. (And it is a good place to see also. So come visit sometime!)
Suzy
I was so moved by this post.
I had a girl in my kindergarten classroom last school year who clearly identifies as a boy. I wrote about it at The Peace Tree, if you want to read it. The link is on a post on my site, a few weeks back.
Unfortunately for my student, we have a useless school psychologist who did nothing for the child and family. I'm so glad that in your district you have a good program for kids who fall outside the gender normative box.
Excellent post, Suzy. Again, thanks.
Pagan
Got the book.
Didn't realize that it was written by the author of Define "Normal", which is on our reading list at my school, and which is also quite good.
Pagan Sphinx -- I didn't realize that you were also a Kgn teacher. If Ed told me, I had forgotten. Solidarity, sister! I will most definitely go and read what you wrote.
Read it over the past two days.
Liked the narrator, liked the brother (Luna). Very vivid, very emotional.
Didn't like the parents much, and I know we weren't supposed to. I got the point that they were supposed to be clueless, but I detected just a few too many suburban stereotypes there.
Still, it's a winner. I'll be getting a copy for my classroom collection. This was a very brave move by this author, and I think she pulled it off.
Parents aren't done very well in a lot of YA novels. I wonder why?
Post a Comment